First, let’s be clear that like most things Pittsburgh, our local flavors vary by suburb. The Pittsburgh Salad is no exception. But most will agree that whatever the actual salad base, it’s topped with a combination of fries, cheese and either grilled chicken or steak.
This is the first time we’ve made a Pittsburgh Salad in South Africa, but we needed a practice run. Our favorite restaurant here in Pretoria is having a Superbowl party Sunday night/Monday morning (we’re 7 hours ahead of Pittsburgh) and they’re putting a Pittsburgh Salad on the menu. Even though our team isn’t playing, the managers are NFL fanatics, and Steelers fans for life!
Of course. But also, Steelers world.
So I was shocked to Google “Pittsburgh Salad” in preparation for today’s blog only to find that Food Network has a Pittsburgh Salad that is absolutely nothing like a traditional Pittsburgh Salad, let alone something your average Pittsburgher would consider eating. It looks like it should be sitting pretty in some pretentious overpriced restaurant, where food is more art than food. In other words, not typical Pittsburgh fare. I don’t normally leave negative reviews, but the image of Pittsburgh, particularly the traditional food, is important to me. I don’t know where they imported that recipe from, but send it back. And if you’re a Pittsburgher and agree, please don’t hesitate to click the link above and add your opinion on that recipe. I mean, just…ugh.
So what is a Pittsburgh Salad…to me?
Well, Kurt and I have a favorite that was from a little bar and restaurant west of Pittsburgh, and we ate there for about ten years until we moved to Washington County. I tried Pittsburgh Salads every place I ate around the ‘burgh, including a few varieties which added coleslaw (I think they riffed that from Primanti’s) but the recipe I’m sharing with you today is as close to our original favorite as we’ve been able to make here.
Like I said above, Pittsburghers tastes will vary by region, and so we will always have good debates about our favorite wing sauce, our favorite beer, and our favorite Pittsburgh Salad. But generally, most of us natives want a good portion of fries, cheese and meat with our veggies. Let the imports eat the food-as-art salads.
PITTSBURGH SALAD BY TRAVELING MARLA
(made as close to memory as possible while living in South Africa)
Lettuce: we combine iceburg and mixed baby greens
4-6 bell pepper strips (any color will work but green is normally what’s used)
1 boiled eggs (cut into halves or quarters)
1/8-1/4 onion (usually either sweet onions or red onions depending on taste)
4-6 cucumber slices
Pittsburgh topping of fries (“chips” for South Africans and Brits), melted cheese and grilled chicken or steak
Toss together lettuce, peppers and onions. Garnish with eggs and cucumber
large handful of fries (“chips”) – Kurt makes these homemade in a pot of cooking oil.
handful mozzarella and cheddar cheese combo (shredded)
1/2 breast or fillet grilled chicken or steak cut into strips.
We usually season our fries and chicken with a bit of salt and a bit of spice to your taste.
*The topping is microwaved separately to melt the cheese onto the fries and chicken and then placed on top of the salad so that the salad is cold but the topping hot.
In the states, we purchase bottled Ranch dressing, which is quite tasty.
Homemade Ranch, 4-6 servings:
1/2 cup buttermilk (you can make buttermilk by adding 1 large spoon of vinegar per 1 cup milk and letting it sit for 5 minutes)
3 large spoons of creme fraiche (sour cream)
2 large spoons of mayonnaise
1/2 teaspoon of dijon mustard
1 tsp dill seasoning
1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
dash of tabasco sauce
Eat and enjoy!
Western Pennsylvanians: Feel free to add your own Pittsburgh Salad recipe or variation in the comments below!!
South Africans: I’d love for you to make this Pittsburgh Salad and see if you like it. If, after tasting it you want to alter it, please come back and tell me what you did to Africanize it! 🙂
P.S. I double-dog dare you to make this salad and not crave fries (chips) on your salads in the future.
Want to join us for the Superbowl party? I’ll be there in my black and gold, taking photos and writing another article for you next week. But if you want to join us, ACT FAST because they need an accurate head count for the food!
Here are the details:
SUPERBOWL PARTY FEB.3 AT MO-ZAM-BIK RESTAURANT SILVER LAKES BRANCH
Charlie, the manager at Mo-zam-bik, has been kind enough to organize a Superbowl party. He is planning to show the game on a big screen and serve food and drinks starting from 12:30am onward on Mon. morning. If you are interested please call him at 012 817-2014 or email him at email@example.com.